Judge Delays Sentencing Over Cell Phone Privacy Issue

EASTON, Pa. – A Northampton County judge on Friday delayed sentencing a former Moravian College student for the robbery of a fellow student until she could review a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that could impact his case.

A jury in September convicted Alkiohn Dunkins of robbery, simple assault, conspiracy and receiving stolen property in connection to the February 2017 robbery of a Moravian College student in Hassler Hall. The now 20-year-old was scheduled to be sentenced on Friday.

Defense attorney Michael Diamondstein, who was retained after the trial, asked Judge Paula Roscioli to consider a June ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court that dealt with, what he deemed in court papers, nearly identical Fourth Amendment issues. The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable searches and seizures.

Before trial, the defense had asked the court to suppress cell phone information obtained by Moravian College police without a warrant. Specifically, police used cell-site records for any wireless, internet-enabled device connected to the college’s wireless network to track Dunkins’ whereabouts the night of the robbery.

The system’s 1,300 antennae “inadvertently” track a student’s physical location through their connected devices, such as cellphones, as they move about campus, according to court papers. Dunkins argued that the use of the data violated his state and federal rights to privacy.

In denying Dunkins’ motion to suppress the cell phone records, Roscioli ruled before trial that policies in the Moravian College student handbook make it clear that any connections made to the campus wireless network are subject to inspection by the school at any time.

She noted that includes law enforcement and that users have no expectation of privacy regarding that electronic information.

Diamondstein filed a motion earlier this month asking the court to grant Dunkins a new trial based on the U.S. Supreme Court case that dealt with the very issue of the use of cell-site location information.
The case involved a defendant accused in multiple robberies.

Cell-site records placed the defendant’s cell phone near four of the robberies at nearly the exact time of the robberies, according to court papers. Authorities secured court orders for those records, and the Supreme Court found that a request for such records constitutes a search for Fourth Amendment purposes.

Justices ruled there is a right to privacy in terms of a person’s physical movements. The high court found that third parties were able to collect data through a cellphone connection to its network, allowing the unintentional tracking of the cellphone user’s movements. The court wrote in its opinion that “when the government tracks the location of a cell phone it achieves near perfect surveillance, as if it had attached an ankle monitor to the phone’s user,” according to court papers.

Diamondstein argues that the student handbook fails to alert students that “their right to privacy in their physical movements can be or would be eliminated by using the college network.” The defense argues it would be a “wanton miscarriage of justice” to sentence Dunkins following a trial in which evidence that was illegally obtained was not suppressed.

On Friday, Diamondstein argued that signing the student handbook and waiving a right to privacy would allow police to collect information if someone, for instance, downloaded child pornography or made threats using the college’s system. But the waiver is not sufficient for what amounts to geo-tracking a person’s movements, he said.

The waiver does not indicate that the college can essentially use the system to track your movements and draw a dotted line as a student moves from one location on campus to another, Diamondstein said. If the waiver makes that clear, a student can switch off the wi-fi connection on a cell phone, he said.

Assistant District Attorney Richard Pepper, who prosecuted the case, argued the Supreme Court ruling cited by the defense does not apply because it was an extremely narrow application in that particular case.

The data collection used by investigators amounted to a cell tower dump, Pepper argued. Authorities did not seek Dunkins’ information but rather all information captured by the system, he said.

Dunkins made the conscious decision to carry his cell phone while committing the robbery, Pepper said. He could have turned his phone off or left it at home, he said.

“So, he did consent to what counsel said he didn’t knowingly consent to,” Pepper said.

Roscioli delayed sentencing in order to review the U.S. Supreme Court ruling and it potential impact on the Dunkins case.

The robbery victim, a known drug dealer on campus, told police that he was robbed in his dorm room. He told police that two men rushed in wearing ski masks. One pointed a gun at him and stole $1,000.

Another student later told police that Dunkins told him about the robbery.

Notable Cases

Pretrial Intervention Program That Accepted Ray Rice Is Rarely Granted

We were concerned that Mr. Rice would be treated more harshly because of his celebrity status. We are thankful that he was not. We are thankful that he was given the same treatment as anyone else in a similar situation.

- Michael J. Diamondstein
Baltimore Ravens running back Ray Rice will be allowed to enter a program to avoid prosecution in an alleged assault of his now-wife. Upon successful completion of the program — which will be a minimum of one year — the third-degree charge of aggravated assault causing serious bodily injury would be dismissed. The arrest would remain on his record, but with no conviction.
Pretrial Intervention Program That Accepted Ray Rice Is Rarely Granted
Notable Cases

Pennsylvania and Maryland Prosecutors Drop Child Sex Abuse Cases After Diamondstein Cross Examination

“Michael Diamondstein is the best lawyer on Earth. He saved my life.”

- DT
DT had spent three years in jail and was facing lifetimes more for multiple counts of child rape in Pennsylvania and Maryland. But Michael Diamondstein’s thorough investigation and strategic cross-examination forced prosecutors to withdraw their case mid-jury trial.
Pennsylvania and Maryland Prosecutors Drop Child Sex Abuse Cases After Diamondstein Cross Examination
Notable Cases

Life Sentence Vacated After Decades in Prison

“The district attorney recognized the inequities in the case and we are thankful for the compassion and justice they decided was appropriate.”

- Michael Diamondstein
Mark Young had been serving a life sentence for what prosecutors say was his role as a coconspirator in a 1974 bar robbery that ended in the shooting death of a patron. The 67-year-old Young, who maintained his innocence for almost 50 years, is now slated to be released from prison after a negotiated guilty plea. The judge vacated Young’s previous conviction and sentence.
Life Sentence Vacated After Decades in Prison
Notable Cases

Michael J. Diamondstein Secures Client’s Release from Pennsylvania Prison after 37 Years

He took his first free breaths this afternoon after almost 40 years, and he is very happy and humbled.

- Michael J. Diamondstein
Willie Stokes's release comes after the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania vacated his murder conviction, concluding that the state violated Stokes's constitutional rights by "withholding" crucial evidence about the false testimony of a key witness in the case, according to court documents.
Michael J. Diamondstein Secures Client’s Release from Pennsylvania Prison after 37 Years
Notable Cases

Diamondstein Prevails on Murder Charge for Rapper

Mr. Diamondstein saved my life. He is the best there is.

- Monte Small Atwell aka Benjy
Despite that fact that multiple videos showed local rap singer, Monte Small Atwell aka Benjy killing the decedent, a Philadelphia jury found Mr. Atwell Not Guilty of Murder. The video clearly showed that the unarmed decedent was chasing Mr. Atwell. Mr. Atwell’s attorney, Michael Diamondstein litigated a very effective self-defense case. After a number of withering cross examinations and a closing wherein Mr. Diamondstein exhorted the jurors that his client “would rather be judged by 12 than carried by 6” the jury agreed that Mr. Atwell’s actions were justified.
Diamondstein Prevails on Murder Charge for Rapper
Notable Cases

Six Narcotics Officers Acquitted in Federal Corruption Trial

The things that were said about these honorable men and police officers over the last eight to 10 months were ridiculous. A lot of people in this city owe these heroes an apology.

- Michael J. Diamondstein
Six members of an elite Philadelphia narcotics squad were acquitted of federal corruption charges – a verdict the men described as “vindication” after nearly a decade of federal scrutiny surrounding their conduct. A jury of six men and six women took 5 1/2 days to reject prosecutors’ arguments that former Officers Thomas Liciardello, Brian Reynolds, Michael Spicer, Perry Betts, Linwood Norman, and John Speiser routinely beat and robbed drug suspects during their time as members of the Narcotics Field Unit.
Six Narcotics Officers Acquitted in Federal Corruption Trial
Notable Cases

DA Seth Williams, in Federal Court, Pleads Not Guilty to Corruption Charges

This indictment is 24 hours old and yet too many politicians and commentators have already tried and convicted Seth Williams in the media. Simply because the government makes explosive allegations in a complaint doesn’t mean they’re going to prove it in a court of law.

- Michael J. Diamondstein
Philadelphia District Attorney Seth Williams pleaded not guilty to 23 counts of fraud, extortion, and bribery-related charges. But the problems of the city’s cash-strapped top prosecutor continued to mount outside the courtroom, a day after federal authorities accused him of repeatedly selling his influence to wealthy benefactors willing to bankroll his luxury tastes.
DA Seth Williams, in Federal Court, Pleads Not Guilty to Corruption Charges
Notable Cases

When Your Freedom Is at Stake, You Need a Tenacious Litigator

The man gave me my life back.

- Yusef Bey
It's 8:00 on a September morning but Michael Diamonstein has already been in his office for hours. A criminal defense lawyer, Diamondstein likes to be prepared before he goes to court. That preparation paid off to get an innocent man cleared of all charges.
When Your Freedom Is at Stake, You Need a Tenacious Litigator
Notable Cases

DA’s Office Drops Murder Charges in North Philly Shooting

Tremendous day, not only for Mr. Hill but for the entire Philadelphia justice system.

- Michael J. Diamondstein
With evidence missing and the investigation tainted by the involvement of a detective who pleaded guilty to impeding justice, the District Attorney’s Office has withdrawn murder charges against a 28-year-old man, Dante Hill, in a 2011 shooting outside a North Philadelphia sports bar.
DA’s Office Drops Murder Charges in North Philly Shooting
Notable Cases

Exclusive: Claire Risoldi to Pay Less for Insurance Fraud Scheme, Still Hopes to Avoid Jail Time

Diamondstein added that Berks County Senior Judge Stephen Lieberman, who is now overseeing the case, has authority to reconsider the sentence made by the previous judge, who retired last year.

Michael Diamondstein argued the original jail sentence is illegal because the previous judge assigned the case failed to address if Risoldi was eligible for re-entry, which would allow her to be released from jail early.
Exclusive: Claire Risoldi to Pay Less for Insurance Fraud Scheme, Still Hopes to Avoid Jail Time
Notable Cases

Prosecution Failure Leads to Dismissal of Philadelphia Drug Cases

On behalf of Mr. Jordan, we are extremely happy that that the Superior Court upheld the sound decision of Judge Means.

- Michael J. Diamondstein
On October 10, 2014, the Pennsylvania Superior Court upheld a lower court’s ruling that by failing to provide the defense with a copy of police paperwork in a criminal case (Com. v. Jordan, T., 175 EDA 2014 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2014 )), the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania was barred from the evidence at trial.
Prosecution Failure Leads to Dismissal of Philadelphia Drug Cases